Showing posts with label Princess and the Pea. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Princess and the Pea. Show all posts

Friday, March 23, 2012

The Princess and The Pea by James Finn Garner


What is it?
The Princess and the Pea

Who wrote it?
James Finn Garner

Where can it be found?
in: Once Upon a More Enlightened Time: More politically Correct Bedtime Stories

Adaptation?
Yes! Of the ‘politically correct’ variety.

My thoughts in exactly 10 words:
‘PC’ to the extreme unearths the flaws in this story.

Friday, March 16, 2012

The Princess And The Pea by Hans Christian Andersen




What is it?
The Princess and the Pea

Who wrote it?
Hans Christian Andersen
(Compiled by Russell Ash and Bernard Highton

Where can it be found?
A Classic Illustrated Edition: Tales From Hans Christian Andersen
  
Adaptation?
I’m not entirely sure. It is certainly shorter than other versions I know, but whether that is in the editing, I don’t know.

My thoughts in exactly 10 words:
This Prince has ridiculous constructs about women. Thin-skinned indeed!

Extended thoughts:
More so in this version than in others, I was struck by how unreasonable the prince was in his search for a wife. She had to be a real princess (italics from the book) and every princess he met, the world over, “wasn’t quite right”. It begs to question if he actually wanted to marry at all, or if the whole thing was a charade to appease parents who wanted him to marry. It gets a bit silly. And who says that such a ‘Thin-skinned’ woman maketh a real princess anyway? Dose that imply that real royalty has never done a day’s work and has had no opportunity get thick-skin? Is the queen equally afflicted by these disproportional bruises? Should they see a doctor? And why, oh why, would a real princess appear on the doorstep in the middle of a thunder storm, looking a mess and simply claiming she was a princess? Something smells of a con job…

I do love the Edmond Dulac illustration that accompanies it though. He has a fantastic way with perspective and sweeping angles.


Favourite Quote:
“The pea was placed in the royal museum, where it can still be seen, unless someone has taken it.”

Moral of the story in my own words:
(Mmm, this one is hard).
If you’re too picky in finding a partner, you might end up with a lying, homeless person with a medical condition. 




Find it on Goodreads